A decade after the UK entered into a hasty public vote that split the nation and caused turmoil, a advisory emerges from beyond the Irish Sea: it could happen again.
Authorities and electorate sleepwalked into Brexit and the same could occur with a referendum on a unified Ireland, initiating disturbances for which nobody is equipped.
That is the message from two respected commentators from both sides of the Irish border who have collaborated to scrutinise the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland exiting the UK to form a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.
Political Structures Ill-Equipped
The author and columnist and Sam McBride, have found that the administrative systems in Ireland and Britain are woefully ill-prepared for a potentially tense and seismic referendum.
"The crucial insight of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that events can come out of the blue and can gain traction rapidly," the commentator remarked. "It is my view that the governmental framework of our archipelago remains extremely volatile."
Book Publication Aims to Stir Debate
The duo have studied the governmental, economic and cultural reasons for any constitutional change in a volume, Examining Irish Unification, released by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.
They aim to stir debate on the topic with a series of public talks that will take them to Westminster in the coming weeks.
"What haunts everybody, or must worry everybody, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," stated O’Toole.
"We must avoid a national vote on a thumbs up-thumbs down, vague proposition whose consequences have remained undefined because then you land with an highly divided society where those defeated are not reconciled to losing and the people who have won don't know precisely what it is that they have won."
Governmental Mandate
Under the Belfast Agreement, the Northern Ireland government minister must arrange a referendum on Irish unity if it appears likely that a most voters would approve.
Sinn Féin and other pro-unification groups argue this point is imminent, and a non-profit called Ireland’s Future has built momentum, but both governments and unionists downplay the prospect, leaving it unclear if and when there might be a referendum.
Lack of Substantive Discussion
Partisan language for and against unification has hidden the lack of substantive discussion, stated McBride.
"People tend to be supportive or opposed the concept but the concrete planning which may surpass that to make it possible is mostly absent. A lot has gone on in scholarly circles but hardly any elected officials or advocates want to engage with even the basics. To illustrate, which kind of country might be preferred? Unitary? Federal?"
Book's Approach
In the book, neither author endorses unity or the status quo. They authors two articles that seek objectivity in presenting the argument for a united Ireland and the rationale against, gathering financial and social data, previous instances and structural examples.
Discussions cover identity markers, taxes, healthcare systems, pensions, public liabilities and the threat of loyalist violence. The goal is to inform and stimulate dialogue.
"There is significant curiosity in the subject but there is still lacking a discussion," said the writer. "Discussion implies an acceptance of the concept that there may exist good arguments on each side."
Simultaneous Plebiscites
A referendum in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where voters claim they favour unification but refuse paying higher taxes or introducing a alternative symbol to acknowledge pro-UK communities' UK heritage.
"Authorities in Dublin must work out what the plan from pro-unification movements is beyond just stating: 'We want a unified Ireland and we love you'," said the commentator.
Probability of Public Vote
The journalist considers a national vote in his era is probable and that it could happen suddenly. "You could have just a reckless or a bad or a feckless secretary of state who declares: 'Let's just do this and settle the matter.'"
Each of the nationalists and pro-UK supporters have plausible, justified arguments, he said. "One side will succeed here and the other side will in the end not succeed but each side has got important lessons to acquire from the other's arguments."
Request for More Extensive Debate
Westminster must join the dialogue, said O’Toole. "This concerns the United Kingdom. It's a British issue as much as it is an Irish question."